Komplaint

Native Instruments had the music geek scene on Twitter in a brief frenzy today when they announced the release of Komplete 6.

Komplete has always been an attractive bundle, providing just about every type of software instrument a producer could dream of. Look at what Komplete 5 offered:

  • Absynth 4: A unique, flexible synthesizer
  • Akoustik Piano: Recreations of upright and grand pianos
  • B4 II: A recreation of the Hammond B3 organ
  • Battery 3: A very flexible drum sampler
  • Elektrik Piano 1.5: Recreations of classic electric pianos
  • FM8: A powerful frequency modulation synthesizer
  • Guitar Rig 3: Recreations of classic and modern guitar amps and effects
  • Kontakt 3: One of the most capable software samplers on the market
  • Massive: An analog-inspired synthesizer
  • Pro-53: A recreation of the classic Sequential Circuits Prophet-5 synthesizer
  • Reaktor 5: An incredibly powerful modular sound design and synthesis environment.

That’s a pretty versatile collection, to say the least. Now look at what Komplete 6 offers:

  • Absynth 5
  • Battery 3
  • FM8
  • Guitar Rig 4 Pro
  • Kontakt 4
  • Massive
  • Reaktor 5

Absynth, Kontakt and Guitar Rig have all seen substantial upgrades, but the workhorse keyboard collection (Akoustik Piano, Elektrik Piano, B4 II and Pro-53) has disappeared. Granted, you could argue that the “vintage keys” craze is so 1999, and from a marketing perspective you would be right. Trouble is, NI doesn’t sell products to marketers. They sell to musicians, and these instruments are still used constantly in virtually every style of modern music.

The most troubling think about Komplete 6, however, is Reaktor. It has now been over four years since it received a major upgrade. While Reaktor may not be the most popular instrument in NI’s lineup, it’s the one that synth geek power users love the most because it provides them with the tools and freedom to build whatever they want. The importance of supporting this kind of innovative activity cannot be overstated. It has been the driving force behind every major advance in music technology, from Les Paul’s early experiments with multitrack recording to Tom Dowd’s 8-track, Bob Moog’s modular synthesizer and the current community of makers, circuit benders and iPhone programmers who are constantly seeking new ways to create sound and music.

Native Instruments had (and may still have) a chance to align themselves with the emerging DIY music tech scene, but by neglecting Reaktor for so long, they are alienating their most important users. Not the emo kid dialing in high gain guitar sounds through cheap headphones, the hack producer throwing other people’s loops together to make another generic pop track, or anyone else who would just as happily use another developer’s version of this year’s hottest app. They’re pushing aside the power users who would have stayed with them for the long term on the strengths of their most innovative products.

This is especially surprising in light of Cycling74‘s recent announcement of Max for Live, a version of Max/MSP (Reaktor’s only real competition) that is designed to integrate with Ableton Live. Ableton already has a strong following among electronic composers, and by teaming with Cycling74 they are demonstrating a solid understanding of their core user base.

One can only hope that Native Instruments will wake up and give their customers similar treatment.

Update: The Home Of Zargon details more issues with Native Instruments customer support.

Post to Twitter Post to Plurk Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to MySpace Post to Ping.fm Post to Reddit Post to StumbleUpon

Notes on Snow Leopard Compatibility

I upgraded to Mac OSX 10.6 Snow Leopard on my mid-2006 17″ MacBook Pro (Core Duo, 2GB RAM, 320GB 7400RPM HD) and was very impressed with the speed and seamlessness of the installation. Of course, your experience will vary depending on the software and hardware you use. Here are a few notes about my system:

Apple Logic Pro 9

This is a no-brainer, because Logic 9 was designed for Snow Leopard. I tested it with a recent project that used Native Instruments Akoustik Piano, several instances of the Vienna Instruments plugin and Toontrack Superior 2.0. Under Leopard (Mac OSX 10.5), I had to freeze tracks to play the project smoothly. Under Snow Leopard, I was able to play the track (with a few hiccups), albeit with the audio driver’s buffer set to 512 samples. Logic 9 seems perform better under Snow Leopard than it did under Leopard, I haven’t measured the difference with any accuracy.

Native Instruments Komplete

I was pleasantly surprised that Native Instruments announced compatibility of all their hardware and software in advance of Snow Leopard, with no need for upgrades. I don’t use NI hardware, but can confirm that all the Audio Unit plugins pass validation and appear to work normally.

Vienna Instruments

VSL didn’t make a formal announcement about Snow Leopard in advance, but a few users who had access to the Snow Leopard developer beta confirmed in the VSL forums that the Vienna Instruments plugin and Vienna Ensemble host were compatible. My first impressions have been positive. Both plugins appear faster and smoother under Snow Leopard.

Toontrack Superior 2.0

A representative from Toontrack made an informal announcement in their forum that Toontrack’s products should be compatible with Snow Leopard. I haven’t tested the mixer or bounce features yet, but basic operation seems a bit faster.

MOTU 828mkI

MOTU made a last-minute announcement that version 1.4.23 of their Firewire driver was compatible with Snow Leopard. All MOTU Firewire audio interfaces use the same driver, so they should all work. The only glitch I noticed was the aforementioned Logic 9 project, which played adequately with the buffer set to 512 samples, but wouldn’t play at all with the buffer set to 1024 samples.

M-Audio MIDISPORT 4×4

I have the original model of the M-Audio MIDISPORT 4×4, which M-Audio states is not compatible with Snow Leopard (the Anniversary Model is listed as compatible, but only in class-compliant mode), so I was surprised to find that it worked perfectly. I have heard the same from other M-Audio users about both MIDI and audio hardware. It appears that the installers for M-Audio’s drivers do not work with Snow Leopard, but the drivers themselves are fine. Therefore, you may be okay if the drivers are installed under Leopard before you upgrade. I can’t guarantee that this will work. Even if it does, it’s far from an ideal situation because you’re screwed if you have to reinstall the drivers before M-Audio releases an update. If you use M-Audio hardware, think twice about upgrading to Snow Leopard until M-Audio provides updated drivers. If you decide to try it, make sure you have a backup plan.

Related News

PT Dudes reports that Pro Tools 8 works with Snow Leopard.

Post to Twitter Post to Plurk Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to MySpace Post to Ping.fm Post to Reddit Post to StumbleUpon

Stunning Controller for Native Instruments B4

Create Digital Music has posted details on a beautiful, full-size hardware controller for the Native Instruments B4 virtual instrument. This is absolutely killer, must-see work.

Read about the B4 Controller at Create Digital Music
Visit the B4 Controller website


B4 Controller - www.m-berger.de

B4 Controller - www.m-berger.de


Post to Twitter Post to Plurk Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to MySpace Post to Ping.fm Post to Reddit Post to StumbleUpon